
K and I met with our lawyer yesterday to finalize our Powers of Attorney and to talk about some details regarding using a known sperm donor (something we're seriously considering). Our lawyer had to call in two other lawyers from her firm to be our witnesses for the POAs, and after signing everything, one of those lawyers (an old, straight, married, white guy... not that there's anything wrong with that...) said, "You're getting married? Where do you live?" He then went on to say that it was a "BAD decision" to get married legally in MA (which we're doing), given that we live in RI, a state that doesn't yet recognize gay marriage. The reason? We won't be able to get divorced without moving to MA for a year first. While he's certainly correct about the latter statement, the conclusion that we shouldn't even get married seems ludicrous. Do most people have a contingency plan (i.e. divorce) 6 months before they say their I-do's? If so, I don't want to be one of those people.
Today we got a hastily handwritten 2-line apology from this lawyer that he clearly wrote under the instruction of our lawyer. The letter even said that our lawyer "told [him] in no uncertain terms that he had been insensitive, and that he apologizes for causing us distress."
What follows is my letter to him:
Thank you for your letter of apology. We believe that advising us against marriage in a state where we can’t get divorced seems logical to you, but to us it is simply insulting. Divorce is the furthest thing from our minds, and the last thing we expect to be confronted with when mentioning our engagement.
Our wedding is planned for this summer. We have spent the last several months excitedly meeting with caterers, photographers, dress-makers, friends and family, putting our hearts into planning the wedding of our dreams. We have also adopted a dog, purchased our first home, and are taking steps toward having our first child. It has been an indescribably joyous and affirming time in our lives and our relationship.
At the same time, we follow closely the struggle for marriage equality in RI and the country as a whole. In recent months, we have marched on Washington and attended hearings at the RI State House. Kris lived in Massachusetts when same-sex marriage passed in 2004, and was actively involved in that movement. We have been celebrants and bridesmaids at the same-sex weddings of our best friends. We have attended the court proceedings that ensured the legal rights of our close friends to parent their own biological and adopted children. We have been denied access to necessary fertility treatments because of our unmarried status. We have followed the struggles of same-sex partners in RI to bury their dead and, indeed, to divorce. We are acutely aware of the inequities that we face as lesbians and as a same-sex couple.
None of these challenges lead us to believe for a moment that we are foolish to celebrate and formalize our love and commitment through the time-honored institution of marriage. If you want to support your same-sex clients in their struggle for equal treatment, you might start by offering congratulations instead of judgment and admonition. If you must offer unsolicited advice, perhaps you should suggest that your clients move to Massachusetts while you continue working on the legislative end to right the inequities in Rhode Island.





